Oh this is right up my alley:
2009 – Week 1 vs. Bills (just watch the fourth quarter and think of the Pats “fans” who were pouring out of the stadium with five minutes left. Also the Titans game was one of the last gasps of the 2007 explosive offense.
2010 – Colts game (Peyton throws a loss-sealing pick), 45-3 Jets game (just ignore the playoff rematch where the Jets uh… won), Packers game was a great back and forth despite Aaron Rodgers being out.
2011 – Opener vs. the Dolpins and the last-minute comeback against the Cowboys were two of my favorites. The Ravens playoff game was epic too.
2012 – @ Jets BUTTFUMBLE! 49ers game was an epic comeback that fell just short but still a great game.
2013 – Lots from this season with so many miracle comebacks… vs. Saints as Brady throws last second GWTD, even more incredible comeback vs. the Broncos, and another vs. the Browns. Destroying the Ravens in Baltimore might’ve been my favorite game though.
2014 – Super Bowl obvs and the Ravens playoff game. Broncos beatdown was one of my all-time favorite game experiences.