No one really knew what the Patriots had with Malcolm Butler heading into 2015. Of course we knew he made one of the greatest plays in Super Bowl history (along with a couple other impressive pass breakups before that), but to the casual fan it was easy to think Butler could be a one-hit wonder who would fade back into the unknown.
The thing about Butler though was that he was making plays on the ball from the moment he stepped on the field in training camp in 2014. Every single practice report had Butler always around the ball and that’s a skill that can’t be taught. Behind the scenes, Butler had shown enough in 2014 for Bill Belichick to believe the Super Bowl hero could be the Pats’ best corner in 2015 and he was right.
When the Patriots declined options on Darrelle Revis and Brandon Browner, and then also dumped Alfonzo Dennard and Kyle Arrington it seemed like a head scratcher. Personally I was pissed because I just couldn’t believe the Patriots would go back to more zone-heavy defensive coverage. It’s just not practical in today’s NFL, yet most of the pundits simply assumed it to be the case without a “shutdown” corner like Revis.
Well Butler (and Logan Ryan) proved them all wrong. They allowed the Patriots to primarily stick with the Cover-1 Man Robber coverage, with Ryan usually taking the bigger receiver and Butler taking the other, often faster one. The thing about Butler in his first year as a starter was that he gave up very few uncontested catches. Anything he gave up, the ball missed his hands by mere millimeters. Some might knock Butler for that, saying that he needs to work on his hands, but it’s truly the sign of a special corner. He’ll start picking off those passes soon enough, and that’s if quarterbacks keep throwing at him.
And another great sign, was even when Butler gave up a big play, he always bounced back.
Add in his feisty, competitive gameday attitude and fearless tackling, and it’s not a stretch to say Butler is the best young cornerback the Patriots have had since Ty Law. Now with more experience he’ll be even more prepared to face the game’s best wide receivers. The sky’s the limit for Butler and there should be a new contract coming to him in the next year.